Lighting Kaiser Fields

SOUNDS LIKE A DONE DEAL!
Tomorrow, Tuesday, September 30, 2014, the Costa Mesa Parks and Recreation Commission will hold a special meeting beginning at 6:00 in City Council Chambers at City Hall to "discuss" installing temporary portable lighting on several playing fields at Kaiser School on the Eastside of Costa Mesa.  I put that word in quotes because it appears the decision has already been made, so the "discussion" will apparently be the commission telling everyone that it's a done deal.

INFORMATION
You can read the agenda announcement HERE and the skimpy details of the single issue on the agenda HERE.

PER THE CHAIRMAN...
Just to give you a flavor for this issue, Parks and Recreation Chairman Byron de Arakal is quite adament that this IS GOING TO HAPPEN, PERIOD!  In a post on a new Facebook forum, Costa Mesa Public Square, in the middle of a long, long discussion with residents and others on this issue, he posted the following statement:
The residents around Harper have been tolerating - relatively patiently i might add - lights at Harper for the past two years. The CM PRC proposed a rotation system as far back as last spring. It WILL be implemented. Beyond that, as long as i am a commissioner i will prioritize the recreational needs of thousands of kids over the short-term inconvenience of residents. We as a community need to recognize that from time to time we need to endure inconveniences for the greater good of the community.

"SNIPPY"...
For those who have signed up for that forum, when you read down through the 90 comments (and counting) you will find several where the exchanges between The Chairman and others to be, er, testy.  I guess that's to be expected, since this is a very touchy issue.  One participant described some of de Arakal's comments as "snippy" - I agree.  He directed at least one of them at me.  I fear my friend - he's the reason this blog exists - has taken on some of the attributes of his benefactors on the City Council who appointed him to the commission - he just doesn't like folks to challenge his views and/or disagree with him.


RELIEF FOR HARPER SCHOOL NEIGHBORS
The reason for lighting Kaiser School fields is to provide some relief for the residents surrounding Harper School, who have been enduring the intrusion - light spill-over and noise - for the past couple years.  Lighting Kaiser School fields would allow elimination of the Harper School lights.  This decision is driven by the conclusion reached by the commission that we MUST have lighted field for kids to practice soccer on in our city.  Independent analysis by residents of some of the numbers used to support this conclusion raise some interesting questions about their accuracy.

NEWPORT BEACH NOT SHARING BURDEN?
And, added to the mix, is the implication that our friends in Newport Beach are not doing their fair share to provide lighted venues for AYSO 97, which includes large numbers of Newport Beach kids.  I don't have facts to support that segment of the issue, one way or the other. 

A CROWD ANTICIPATED
I expect the council chambers will have more than a few interested parties for this special meeting.  I imagine there will be some of my Eastside neighbors in attendance to address both schools situations.  I'll attend and report.  Because it will be held in council chambers I imagine CMTV will televise the meeting live and also make streaming video available to us later.

Of Lights And Trains

A TARDY DISCUSSION
Last week I chose to cover the Skate Park issue extensively instead of attempting to cover all the issues discussed at the Costa Mesa Parks and Recreation meeting on Thursday, June 27th.  My plan was to followup shortly with the balance of the meeting.  I'm finally getting back to it tonight.

TWO ITEMS
There were two other very significant issues on the agenda.  I'm not going to talk about tree removal requests.

LIGHTS VS. PEACE AND QUIET
AYSO District 97 has requested the commission to extend the permit for temporary lights to be used for practices on the Harper School fields.  Many beleaguered neighbors contiguous to the property asked that the lights NOT be permitted, citing noise, odors from the generators (they are portable lights) and spillover lights onto their property.

A ONE-YEAR EXTENSION
Chairman Byron de Arakal led the discussion and, after thoroughly vetting the issue with the help of the other commissioners and stakeholders, he made a motion to extend the use of the lights at Harper School for one more year - the only other unacceptable choice would be to turn the kids away - to revisit the option of using Kaiser School in the future on a rotation basis, to investigate the availability and cost of sound-deadening blankets to wrap the units to cut noise and to guarantee that the lights will be turned off no later than 7:30 p.m. every night.  That motion passed, 4-0.  Commissioner Don Harper was absent from the meeting.

AN OK SOLUTION, FOR NOW
In my view, this solution works for now.  The city is woefully short of fields, particularly lighted fields and especially on the Eastside of our city.  AYSO District 97 is 51% Costa Mesa kids - the remainder come from Newport Beach.  de Arakal promised to come to the homes of folks impacted by the lights on Cabrillo and elsewhere to see and hear the impacts in person.  He also said he would set up meetings with Newport Beach officials to see what can be done to possibly include Mariners School in the "lighted" rotation.

OCME WANTS ANOTHER 25 YEARS
The other big issue on the agenda last Thursday was the expiring agreement between the City and the Orange County Model Engineers - the folks who operate and maintain the model trains in Fairview Park.  The organization has had a permit for 25 years and were requesting a renewal/extension for another 25.

OCME BRINGS GREAT VALUE
Their presentation of the contributions they have made, and continue to make, to the community brought into very sharp focus the value that facility has had in our city for decades.  de Arakal stated emphatically that he, personally, didn't want to see the trains leave the park.


LAND LUST
However, there are those in the community who covet that chunk of land for more playing fields.  The trains occupy 22 acres, roughly in the middle of a 40 acre chunk of the park on the east side of Placentia Avenue.  It is likely that those who lust after that land may make overtures about some kind of re-configuration to "better" utilize the space.  I'm not naming names here, but we all know "it's all about the kids", if you get my drift.

MARKING TIME
de Arakal proposed that the current agreement be extended through the end of 2014.  In the interim the Fairview Park Citizen's Advisory Committee will be going about doing its job of assessing the park, the current uses and the needs of the community in the future.  It is certain that the OCME and the Harbor Soaring Society activities will be discussed at length by that body.

TAKE A LOOK AGAIN IN A YEAR

Once the committee finishes its assignment - hopefully within the next 12 months - de Arakal proposed that the OCME issue be revisited based on the findings of the committee, with the eye toward creating a NEW agreement taking into consideration all the complex factors involved.  Again, he stressed that he doesn't want to see the OCME out of the park.

TOUGH TO SWALLOW
Certainly the good folks of the OCME were not happy with that decision, just as the Harbor Soaring Society was disappointed by their recent one-year extension.  Both organizations have enjoyed much success and have played a big part in the recreational opportunities at Fairview Park and hope to continue to do so out into the future, too.  The specter of parking lots and playing fields being located in areas they presently use make them very nervous.  Personally, I think they have every reason to be nervous about it.

A BITTER, BUT REASONABLE SOLUTION
So, the Parks and Recreation Commission will recommend to the City Council that it extend the current agreement with the OCME for 18 months and base any future agreement on recommendations by the Fairview Park Citizens Advisory Committee.  It's not a great solution for the train folks, but it seems to be a reasonable option under the circumstances.

IT DESERVES WATCHING
That being said, it's going to be interesting to see how this, in fact, does shake out.  I attended the first meeting of the Fairview Park Citizen's Advisory Committee and there were some clear lines drawn that evening when Ron Amburgey and Brett Eckles - who spoke with passion about the need for fields during the Harper School lights issue - both gave strong impressions that they felt the model train area could be used better.  They meant more playing fields.

Harper Lights, Online Fees, Bike Racks In Parks

FOURTH MEETING THIS YEAR
This evening, in their July meeting, the Costa Mesa Parks and Recreation Commission will discuss several interesting issues.  The meeting begins at 6:00 in City Council Chambers at City Hall.  You can read the complete agenda HERE. 

HARPER SCHOOL FIELD LIGHTING
Perhaps the most contentious issue they will address tonight is that of placing portable lights on the soccer fields at Harper School.  The staff report his HERE.  It's my understanding that many neighbors close to Harper School will be on hand to let the commission hear their views.

ONLINE REGISTRATION FEES
Another controversial issue is the fees currently charged for online registration for recreation programs using the Active Net program.  Read that staff report, including attachments, HERE.  There are many who feel the charges are out of line, particularly when used for one-time events with low participation fees.


BIKE RACKS IN CITY PARKS
Also on the agenda is the issue of bicycle racks in city parks.  That agenda is HERE.  When the city council recently made it illegal to lock bikes to rails, posts and other structures somebody forgot about our parks.  How does that happen?  Anyhow, according to the staff report, there are only 38 bicycle parking places in our 29 parks!  The issue tonight will be to consider several alternative bike racks for placement within our city parks.

RECREATION DIVISION REPORT
Perhaps the most interesting item on the agenda is the final one, the Recreation Division Report, HERE.  The numbers in that report are VERY interesting and gives you a real feel for how much are parks and other recreation facilities are actually used by the residents of this city.  This will be new Recreation Manager Bob Knapp's first chance to present this report.